Those of a certain age might recall the Animaniacs. It was an absurdist cartoon with a lot of bits, many referencing the likes of George Burns, Marlon Brando, and other popular public figures from 30 years prior that meant absolutely nothing to 10-year-old me.
One of the bits was "good idea, bad idea," the basic premise of which is right there in the name. I thought it would be fun to revive it for this post on an especially doomed motion before Judge Connolly. Because, while there is much to be learned from the man who climbed Everest, the lesson is often more easily grasped from those unfortunate souls who line the path.
In that vein, I present the lessons that I have gleaned from last Monday's decision in Drake v. General Electric Co., C.A. No. 24-281-CFC (D. Del. Mar. 10, 2025).
Good Idea - Attaching Factual Support for Your Motion
As we've covered in the past, one of the best strategies for a discovery dispute—or any motion—is creating a detailed factual record on, for instance, the actual costs of complying with some request, the difficulty of access some set of documents, or the high cost of vendors. One can find innumerable examples of the Court noting that the losing side of the dispute had presented no more than "attorney argument." At least Judge Burke explicitly encourages the parties to attach affidavits or declarations to their discovery dispute submissions.
Bad Idea - Attaching Your Secretly Recorded Phone Calls
For those curious, there's some ambiguity ...
