
We've written before about how delay can kill your discovery motions. We got another straightforward example on Monday in Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation v. HEC Pharm Co., Ltd., C.A. No. 20-133, D.I. 340 (D. Del. Mar 31, 2025).
There, the defendants sought depositions of two foreign inventors through the Hague convention. The defendants have known the relevance of the inventors' knowledge since at least July, 2022, but only moved for issuance of letters rogatory in December 2024.
The case was stayed for a portion of that time, but in total, the Court found that there was no good reason that it should have taken so long to seek this discovery:
During the teleconference, Defendants' …